The
John Adams Society
February 2008
“Clearly, the time for constitutional reform is now. If not, the time will come when the Constitution will be so far removed from the realities of society and government that it no longer applies. As a consequence, our government will no longer be restrained by a written Constitution. The next step, thus, will be government without limitation and the destruction of any semblance of democracy.” - John W. Whitehead
The United
States Constitution, the
foundation under which we allow ourselves to be governed, has proven
ineffective in dealing with contemporary society and issues the drafters could
never have comprehended. Initially
intended to put explicit limits on the duties of the federal government, the
articles and amendments are so vaguely defined that there is practically no
limit as to what the government can or cannot do.
Broad strokes
of liberty defined in the Bill of Rights have produced undesired
effects: Freedom of the Press has given us photo-stalkers that invade the
privacy of any person deemed a celebrity.
The Right to Bear Arms allows just about anyone to acquire weapons
capable of inflicting great damage on the populace. And a less-than-specific definition of
‘Public Good’ has allowed local governments to confiscate property under the guise
of Eminent Domain, for no better reason than to collect more taxes from a new
owner.
On the other
hand,
the beauty and strength of this document rests in its relative simplicity. Rather than a myriad of statutes and specific
directives addressing the latest social trends and populist views, the
Constitution relies on sound judgment, principle, and the resolve of the people
to ensure their own liberty. One needs
only to look at our 66,000 page income tax code to see the ill effects
congress, government bureaucracy, and special interest groups can inflict when the
law is allowed to change willy-nilly.
The Chairman, who clearly appreciates the value of things
old and quaint, as evidenced by her choice in presidential candidates, has
called for a debate to settle the question:
Resolved: The Constitution is Antiquated
The Debate will be held on